RESEARCH DOSSIER

Portugal and Offshore Finance

Abstract. Portugal's participation in offshore finance is examined through national cross-border investment relationships and the geographically specific International Business Centre of Madeira. The study reconstructs the institutional logic of regional operating aid, examines the enforcement history of Regime III, distinguishes foreign direct investment from pass-through activity, and evaluates economic incidence through regional enterprise and foreign-affiliate statistics. Official 2023 and 2024 data show marked differences between the licensed foreign-affiliate subset's shares of employment and gross value added; a descriptive decomposition demonstrates the limitations of entity counts and accounting aggregates as indicators of regional development. Historical matched-worker research and the 2026 institutional changes contextualize the descriptive findings. The analysis connects these differences to fiscal incidence, investment location, intermediary functions, financial risk and European market discipline. Documentary and accounting evidence supports a multiscale interpretation rather than a blanket classification of Portugal. Conclusions are framed within explicit data and identification limits; no Portugal-specific causal effect, illicit-finance total or new named theory is asserted.

Keywords: Portugal; Madeira; offshore finance; foreign direct investment; special-purpose entities; international business center; regional development; tax competition; state aid; financial intermediation; external accounts; fiscal incidence

Introduction

Portugal participates in offshore finance through a combination of domestic financial intermediation, internationally distributed corporate ownership, inward and outward investment, and the territorially specific institutions of the Autonomous Region of Madeira. These activities connect a national economy to a larger network in which the legal domicile of an entity, the residence of its investor, the location of personnel, the recording of revenues, and the destination of financial resources can differ. The economic importance of these relationships depends on the function performed at each location and on the distribution of the resulting benefits and risks.

The Portuguese case is particularly useful because the internationalization of firms and finance coexists with a regional development instrument operating inside an integrated European market. A regional tax concession can affect the geographical location of genuine economic functions as well as the geographical distribution of reported returns. An enterprise can combine substantive work in Madeira with investments and customers throughout the world. Consequently, the research question concerns the relationship between the incentive, the economic function, and the regional outcome, rather than the presence of a foreign shareholder alone.

This dossier asks how offshore-related capital is organized, how it is measured, what makes a territorially targeted incentive economically effective, and how the institutional constraints on such incentives affect the costs and benefits perceived by firms, workers, taxpayers, and other members of the European economy. It treats economic integration and institutional differentiation as complementary parts of the Portuguese case. Madeira is a focal point, while national financial accounts and European institutional relationships provide the surrounding scale.

The investigation uses comparative institutional analysis, accounting distinctions, a descriptive decomposition of regional enterprise data, a historical case of state aid enforcement, and counterfactual reasoning concerning public finance and local development. It makes no claim to estimate a causal treatment effect from cross-sectional aggregates. It presents original interpretations of the observed relationships within established economic methods; it introduces no new named theory. The evidence horizon is November 2026, with explicit vintages because a figure for 2024 published in 2025 is different from a forecast for 2026.

The economic meaning of offshore participation

Offshore finance involves financial functions mediated through jurisdictions whose economic, fiscal, regulatory, or organizational attributes matter to nonresident participants. In a country-level study, the analytical unit may be a bank, a company, an investment fund, a portfolio position, an intragroup loan, a holding entity, a specialized maritime enterprise, or a particular regional regime. Assigning the same economic behavior to every unit registered within a jurisdiction would obscure differences in productive activity and risk.

A holding company may own a manufacturing subsidiary outside Portugal; a Portuguese subsidiary may be controlled by a foreign parent through an intermediate holding company; a resident bank may extend credit to nonresident borrowers; a business may sell services overseas using resident employees. These relationships each generate cross-border financial consequences. Only a subset depends materially on jurisdictional intermediation in the sense relevant to offshore economics. The existence of a bilateral financial relationship is a starting observation, and the importance of jurisdictional incentives is a separate empirical question.

A useful distinction is between financial stocks, transactions, income, and production. The stock of foreign-owned equity measures a balance-sheet relationship at a particular date. A transaction represents a change arising during a period from an economic transaction. Income may arise as interest, dividends, or retained earnings. Gross value added measures productive output less intermediate inputs. A large investment position can coexist with limited resident employment, while a business providing high-value services may have modest tangible assets. Each indicator describes a different dimension of the economy.

The Portuguese offshore question therefore has several geographical layers. Portugal is the national statistical reporting economy, Madeira is a regional economy and a site of a specific incentive, while the international investor's economy and the ultimate destination of investment may be entirely different. The study uses the national scale for external accounts and the regional scale for local outcomes. The geographic scope of the conclusion follows the scope of the evidence.

Historical development and regional integration

Madeira's international business arrangements developed as an instrument of regional economic policy. The documentary history underlying the later state aid dispute is recorded in the European Commission's Regime III decision (2020), including Portuguese measures dating to 1980 and 1982 and subsequent European authorization decisions. That history matters because the original rationale for regional support framed economic activity as a response to the extra costs of operating in an outermost region. Successive arrangements had to be understood within a changing European framework rather than as permanent, unconditional tax attributes.

Island economies face transport costs, restricted local market size, exposure to external demand, and potential shortages of specialized labor. Tradable services, internationally connected businesses, and activities with relatively low physical transport requirements can diversify the local economy. A tax concession changes the cost of locating selected functions in a region; complementary institutions determine whether the opportunity becomes a durable local capability.

The incentive's regional rationale and the firm's private rationale can nevertheless diverge. A government may value incremental jobs and resident earnings, whereas shareholders compare the after-tax return across locations. If the registered location is easier to change than the underlying productive operation, a subsidy can induce a legal or financial relocation with a smaller real relocation. This mechanism explains the need to distinguish the attraction of overseas business from the development of an island economy.

A mature assessment evaluates successive authorization and licensing cohorts separately. The criteria, rate, maximum benefit, enforcement practice, method of counting jobs, and effective dates can vary across cohorts. Combining all years under one undifferentiated policy variable would yield misleading estimates of business response. When authorities change the rules, observed entry and exit may reflect expected policy changes as well as contemporaneous economic conditions.

European integration gives Madeira access to a wider market and places regional selectivity within a common institutional order. The resulting arrangement combines territorial specialization with supranational discipline. A change in one level of government may alter expected returns for firms and the fiscal position of another. This multilevel character distinguishes the Portuguese case from the economic analysis of a stand-alone small jurisdiction whose domestic policy is determined under a different constitutional and international framework.

The Madeira International Business Centre

The International Business Centre of Madeira, also associated with the Madeira Free Zone, encompasses a territorially delimited set of licensed activities. Its economic functions include industrial activity, international services, maritime business, and nonfinancial corporate holdings within relevant statutory conditions. Each activity has its own combination of labor demand, tangible and intangible capital, customer geography, and exposure to international regulation.

Portugal's tax authority publishes the consolidated Article 36-A of the Tax Benefits Statute (2026). The domestic text provides a 5 percent corporate income tax rate for specified qualifying income of entities licensed between January 2015 and December 2026, with a statutory benefit horizon through December 2033, as amended in December 2025. Eligibility, exclusions, activity requirements and limitations qualify that headline rate. These dates describe the retrieved domestic wording; the applicable EU authorization and the facts of an individual enterprise require separate examination. The economic analysis consequently works with conditional benefits, not an unconditional rate applicable to all companies or all transactions.

The statute ties the size of the benefit to economic indicators and employment bands. This relationship is intelligible as an effort to match the advantage received by an enterprise to a measurable regional contribution. Employment is a visible indicator and a relatively direct object of social policy. Revenue and value added capture additional aspects of economic scale. Each remains an imperfect measure of the incremental regional gain that public policy seeks.

An employment requirement may induce a demand for real workers, while the return attached to crossing a threshold creates a discontinuity in incentives. Two enterprises with similar business potential may face different incentives depending on their position relative to that threshold. This affects recruitment, choices about contracting, the timing of investment and the composition of firms entering the regime. A descriptive association between employment and aid therefore partly reflects eligibility rules themselves.

The region's role as a location for corporate and financial functions should be assessed alongside industrial and maritime functions. A ship registered within a specialized registry can operate internationally. The location of its registration, its operating routes, its beneficial ownership, crew residence, and the suppliers of maritime services are separate economic attributes. A service office, meanwhile, may create local output through intellectual and professional labor even when customers reside abroad. The number of vessels or firms alone cannot establish the contribution to resident incomes.

The regional economic rationale is strongest when an internationally oriented activity retains substantial local functions that would otherwise be absent. Those functions may include technical work, management, administration, procurement, and investment in durable capability. Their value ultimately depends on skills, productivity, compensation, commercial relationships, and the stability of demand after an incentive changes.

The changing fiscal regime and minimum taxation

The consolidated domestic scheme applicable to the 2015–2026 licensing cohort connects taxation to regional activity, the size of employment and measurable economic performance. Article 36-A contains several alternative maximum benefit measures based on economic indicators and a further taxable-base limitation based on employment. Its working-time provisions show that counting people and counting annual labor input are distinct administrative operations. The alignment of relief with actual activity requires a consistent record of each. Statutory criteria and the firm's realized regional contribution answer related but different questions.

The Portuguese Parliament's 2027 Madeira legislative initiative (November 2026) concerns entities licensed from January 1, 2027. At the research cutoff the verified evidence establishes a legislative proposal and consultation, not an enacted successor. This distinction affects investment timing: firms form expectations about later costs while incumbent businesses assess the conditions applicable to their own cohort. Anticipatory entry or delayed entry may occur before the legal change becomes effective. A longitudinal study should separate announcement, enactment, entry into force and actual licensing.

A second institutional constraint arises from Portuguese Law No. 41/2024, which implements the minimum-tax framework for covered groups. Its jurisdiction-level effective tax computation and top-up mechanism differ from the nominal rate of an individual Madeira entity. An economic comparison based on that rate alone may overstate the global fiscal advantage of a covered multinational. Substance-based income exclusion creates additional differences between returns tied to real inputs and other profits. Firm-specific results depend on group scope, covered taxes, qualifying income and the applicable rules.

The coexistence of regional relief and minimum taxation changes the relative economic significance of company functions. A firm's commercial activities may remain valuable even when the benefit of a particular profit location decreases. This creates a distinction between a durable regional business ecosystem and a fiscal advantage vulnerable to international rule changes. Comparing covered and noncovered businesses would require controlling for their systematically different size, ownership and business functions. The economic argument identifies mechanisms rather than predicting a uniform response or computing individual tax liabilities.

State aid enforcement and economic substance

The central historical test is the implementation of Regime III. The 2007 and 2013 Commission approvals linked tax relief to qualifying economic activity in Madeira and employment. In Decision (EU) 2022/1414, adopted on December 4, 2020 and published in August 2022, the Commission found that implementation diverged from the approved conditions. The Commission decision on recovery analyzes the local activity and employment criteria and provides for recovery of incompatible aid with specified individual exclusions.

The disagreement included the relationship between a company's presence and its geographically distributed commercial operations. Portugal emphasized internationally oriented activities and the relevance of a functioning business presence in Madeira. The Commission distinguished a firm's general tax status from the conditions governing the particular regional operating aid. The economic significance of the dispute is that the cost structure of an activity is geographically distributed even where the enterprise is a single legal entity.

The General Court's Madeira Free Zone judgment (2022) dismissed the challenge to the Commission decision. A subsequent Portugal v Commission appeal (Court of Justice, 2024) was dismissed on July 4. The Commission action C-410/26 (2026), brought on April 22, alleged failures to carry out recovery and related obligations in time. This is an allegation brought in litigation, not a new judgment against Portugal. The Utiledulci preliminary ruling (Court of Justice, May 2026) concerned a national tax enforcement procedure arising from the earlier decision. The distinction between the original compatibility determination and its administrative realization matters for expected cash flows and regulatory risk.

Recovery alters the expected return on a location decision. A firm considering an investment weighs the current value of anticipated benefits against the probability and possible magnitude of future repayment, dispute costs, and operational disruption. An apparently favorable statutory rate may therefore coexist with a higher risk-adjusted cost of capital. For a firm with specialized assets tied to Madeira, relocation can also destroy local relationships and create adjustment costs. The relevant policy variables include certainty of administration, clarity of criteria, and predictability of their application.

The Commission's recovery methodology makes clear that the scope of repayment is linked to individual conditions, and that blanket inference from licensing status is inappropriate. The distinction has economic importance: a population of firms with heterogeneous facts cannot be modeled as if every concession were equivalent or every beneficiary had received an incompatible advantage.

A second consequence concerns administration. Tax administration routinely verifies tax declarations according to applicable procedures. A regional aid program also needs evidence capable of establishing the relationship between the subsidized activity and the regional objective. Information sufficient for one purpose may fail to answer the other. Improving the compatibility between these records avoids duplicative compliance while preserving the validity of the evidence used in both contexts.

The enforcement episode also illustrates a commitment problem shared by regional incentives. Firms require stable expectations before investing in specialized assets, while public authorities require credible means of withdrawing benefits when conditions are not met. Stable and enforceable eligibility is economically valuable because it allows firms to anticipate obligations and public bodies to connect expenditure or foregone revenue to their stated objective. Certainty means a predictable conditional arrangement rather than immunity from enforcement.

Portugal's international investment position

National direct investment statistics measure economic connections between Portuguese residents and nonresidents at a scale far beyond Madeira. Banco de Portugal's end-2025 direct investment data reports inward positions of EUR 213.7 billion and outward positions of EUR 78.6 billion. The arithmetic difference between these directional measures is EUR 135.1 billion inward, and the inward position is approximately 2.72 times the outward position. Both derived figures are descriptive comparisons of the cited stock totals.

These magnitudes establish substantial international ownership and financing relationships. They do not give the aggregate value of Portuguese offshore activities. Inward investment may finance ordinary operating businesses, acquisition of established enterprises, real estate, intragroup lending, or internationally distributed holding structures. Outward investment may support sales networks or productive capacity abroad as well as financial intermediation. Different transactions affect domestic production, employment and income differently.

A change in an equity position can arise from reinvested earnings, transactions, price revaluation, exchange-rate movements or other changes in volume. Hence subtracting a prior year's position from the current year's position does not necessarily recover net investment transactions. When investment stock is valued at current or estimated market prices, valuation effects may be particularly important. Researchers must compare stocks with stocks and transactions with transactions and record the valuation basis.

The OECD investment definitions (2025) distinguish the asset/liability presentation from the directional presentation. These views answer different questions, especially in groups with reverse investment and intragroup positions. A difference calculated from inward and outward directional positions should not be reported as the country's entire net international investment position. A country's external balance sheet also includes debt securities, other investment, reserve assets, portfolio equity, derivatives and additional components.

The distinction between residence and control remains fundamental. The immediate investing economy is the residence of the direct counterpart in the chain. The ultimate investor economy seeks to identify the economy behind that chain using a specified control relationship. Neither necessarily identifies the residence of an ultimate natural-person beneficial owner. Different measures reveal different aspects of ownership, exposure and accountability.

For studying Portugal as a potential intermediary, the symmetry of inward and outward positions at entity level is more informative than national totals alone. Aggregation can conceal matching positions in individual intermediaries and unrelated positions elsewhere. Inference about pass-through activity requires disaggregation by type of entity, related-party relationships and geography. A country can be an important destination for genuine investment while also hosting intermediating entities.

Special-purpose entities and statistical interpretation

A special-purpose entity is an institutional form used to organize particular financial or corporate functions. The OECD's special cases guidance (2025) includes low employment, limited physical presence and limited production among relevant classification characteristics. Classification uses the complete statistical definition; headcount alone is an incomplete diagnostic. Institutional residence, counterpart relationships and economic function determine how financial positions enter the accounts.

Banco de Portugal publishes a quarterly transaction series for direct investment excluding SPEs in BPstat. The existence of an ex-SPE measure permits a more precise statistical comparison than an undifferentiated national headline. It separates a defined category of entities, not every form of cross-border intermediation. The series is identified here as an empirical resource; its observations have not been downloaded or estimated in this study.

Damgaard, Elkjaer, and Johannesen (2019), in What Is Real and What Is Not in the Global FDI Network?, estimate that close to 40 percent of global direct investment may be attributable to entities providing little substantive connection with the host economy. The authors combine macroeconomic and firm-level sources to distinguish forms of recorded investment and allocate investment to ultimate investor economies. Their estimate is global and method-dependent, referring to 2017. The later 2024 journal article is the published successor of the working paper, not an independent estimate.

Applying that percentage mechanically to Portugal would imply that the national composition matches the global estimated composition. Such an assumption is unwarranted. Country-specific institutions, industrial structure, cross-border ownership patterns, reporting practices and the prevalence of specialized entities are precisely the characteristics under investigation. A reliable national result requires a country-specific dataset and harmonized definitions.

Consider a hypothetical entity with EUR 100 million in equity financing from abroad and an equal-value equity holding abroad. On an unconsolidated residence basis the host reports both a large liability and a large asset. If the entity pays EUR 200,000 to resident employees and local suppliers, that expenditure contributes to regional activity in ways that the EUR 100 million positions alone cannot describe. If the group changes its legal structure without changing ultimate productive assets, reported bilateral investment may change considerably even where group-wide real capital remains stable.

The example uses arbitrary amounts and assumes no valuation changes. Its purpose is accounting explanation. It does not estimate Portuguese positions or characterize any named enterprise. It demonstrates why one should examine intermediate ownership and local function jointly rather than deduct an arbitrary fraction of inward investment to derive real production.

The OECD's 2025 FDI benchmark recommends improved information about investment purpose, ultimate investor and host economies, and pass-through financing. Application to Portuguese datasets requires checking methodological vintages and whether revised standards have actually been implemented. A policy analyst should retain separately the series as published, a harmonized historical series, and any analytical decomposition. Revisions should not be confused with behavioral responses to an incentive.

Foreign affiliates and the regional economy

The regional foreign-affiliate statistics for Madeira provide a different perspective from direct investment stocks. DREM's 2024 foreign affiliates release (2025) defines an affiliate for this statistical exercise as a Madeira-resident company controlled by an institutional unit outside Portugal. The population comprises companies and is based on integrated enterprise accounts. Foreign control is a statistical relationship and does not establish eligibility for a particular tax treatment.

The release reports 243 foreign affiliates, approximately 5,078 persons employed, EUR 1,416.3 million turnover, and EUR 420.6 million gross value added in 2024. The subset licensed in the International Business Centre accounted for 17.7 percent of these affiliates, 8.4 percent of their employment, 15.5 percent of turnover, and 24.0 percent of gross value added.

Indicator All foreign affiliates Licensed subset share
Enterprises 243 17.7%
Persons employed 5,078 8.4%
Turnover EUR 1,416.3 million 15.5%
Gross value added EUR 420.6 million 24.0%

Source: DREM (2025), final 2024 foreign-affiliate statistics. Values and shares are reported with rounding. Licensed subset means foreign affiliates licensed within the IBC, not all IBC companies.

These data reveal asymmetry across the measured dimensions. Dividing the subset's GVA share by its employment share gives approximately 2.86. Thus, its reported GVA per employed person was roughly 2.86 times that of the whole foreign-affiliate population. The complement's ratio is 76.0/91.6, approximately 0.83; dividing 2.86 by 0.83 gives approximately 3.44. The licensed subset's aggregate GVA per employee was therefore about 3.44 times that of affiliates outside the subset, subject to rounding and consistent denominator definitions.

This comparison is an original calculation from the official reported shares, not an independent productivity estimate. It captures an aggregate accounting ratio and cannot establish worker-level productivity, tax-induced profit relocation, or the effect of licensing. Sector mix, capital intensity, accounting treatment, company scale and the composition of employment can explain part or all of the difference. The group outside the subset is not a randomized comparison group.

The calculation highlights why simultaneous measurement of enterprise output and labor input is indispensable. A high accounting output-to-employment ratio could arise from specialized high-skill activity or from ownership and business arrangements that generate substantial accounting income with limited labor. Measurement at the firm level would allow differentiation according to compensation, intermediate consumption, depreciation, identifiable capital, business function, and ownership structure.

Combining the rounded shares with DREM's separate proportions of the wider regional nonfinancial company universe gives approximately 0.34% of company count, 0.53% of employment, 2.19% of turnover and 3.17% of GVA for the licensed foreign-affiliate subset. These cross-products preserve the nested numerators and denominators; they do not estimate the footprint of all licensed enterprises. They also exclude sole proprietorships from the company denominator. The results suggest a difference in the function and composition of the subset rather than a direct measure of policy-induced activity.

Foreign affiliates may transfer technology, introduce new business practices and develop supplier relationships. Such effects are different from their direct GVA contribution. A locally headquartered business can be part of an international group while using local labor and suppliers; a holding company can perform comparatively little local work. The net contribution depends on the counterfactual location of those functions and on what the resident workforce and capital would otherwise be doing.

The regional enterprise statistics release (DREM, 2025) provides a broader business context for the same year. Its wider population of 35,650 nonfinancial enterprises and 104,293 employed persons includes both companies and sole proprietorships. It therefore has a different denominator from the foreign-affiliate survey. Regional growth coincident with a licensed international sector does not by itself prove that the sector caused the growth. An adequate evaluation begins by defining the exact firm population and maintaining comparable boundaries over time.

Changes in foreign-affiliate composition across publication vintages

The 2023 foreign-affiliate release (DREM, December 2024) provides a comparison for the next reference year. The four shares are measured within the foreign-affiliate population, not the whole regional economy.

Indicator 2023 reference year 2024 reference year
Companies 19.5% 17.7%
Employment 8.2% 8.4%
Turnover 19.7% 15.5%
GVA 30.5% 24.0%
GVA per employed person relative to all foreign affiliates 3.72 2.86

The last row divides the reported GVA share by the employment share; values are rounded. These are separate publication vintages. The relative output intensity of the licensed subset is visible in both periods, but its magnitude changes. The GVA share decreased by 6.5 percentage points and the employment share increased by 0.2 points between the published observations.

A declining ratio does not establish an absolute reduction in the subset's output. The complement may grow while the numerator remains constant or increases; the composition of the firms and reporting may change. A matched panel is needed to distinguish continuing enterprise growth from ownership changes, entries, exits and license transitions. The observed movement strengthens the argument for following the function and population of enterprises through time rather than extrapolating a fixed ratio.

A further implication concerns evaluation design. If the objective is regional development, the numerator should include resident compensation and locally retained income where observable, not solely enterprise GVA. If the objective is accurate allocation of financial activity, the relevant indicators should also measure balance-sheet positions and intragroup income. A single measure cannot resolve both questions. Descriptive composition data can reveal where more detailed research is needed without prejudging its causal findings.

International trade, maritime activity, and value creation

International commercial operations supply a channel through which firms based in Madeira participate in the world economy. DREM's 2025 international trade release (2026) reports goods exports attributed to IBC-licensed companies of EUR 358.4 million in 2025, compared with EUR 277.4 million in 2024. The nominal increase is EUR 81.0 million, approximately 29.2 percent of the earlier figure. These figures refer to the released international goods trade measure rather than to total exports of services or all economic benefits of the regime.

The attribution of goods exports to a licensed company is not a complete measure of domestic production. A trading firm may handle merchandise that was produced elsewhere. Gross merchandise value may be high relative to margins retained by the trader. Conversely, a high-skill service company can create substantial local value while recording little merchandise trade. An analysis that substituted gross export revenue for local value added would misstate the object of regional development.

The location of a business headquarters can also affect the regional attribution of transactions. The correct accounting treatment depends on the statistical source and its territorial rules. Physical origin of goods, economic ownership, invoicing location and location of the customer are not interchangeable observations. In the context of multinational production, several locations may participate in the same transaction.

Maritime registration illustrates the general problem. Registration, flag-state responsibilities, ownership, chartering, management, physical vessel movement and location of the insurance provider may all differ. Activities associated with registration can bring service work and public revenue. The associated fleet's total asset value, however, is neither the regional capital stock nor a measure of local employment. Similarly, the premium paid by an overseas shipowner to a nonresident insurer should not be counted automatically as Madeira's insurance production.

Relevant comparative data would include locally provided ship management and technical services, compensation, the location of decision-making functions, registry fees, and costs of oversight. The contribution of industrial activities would instead be assessed through local production, imported inputs, wages, capital formation and supplier networks. Applying a single metric indiscriminately across these sectors would favor the activities that mechanically generate the largest accounting amounts.

A useful policy conclusion is that regional export success should be examined in terms of domestic value added embodied in the exports, the durability of business relationships, and the income retained by resident workers and capital owners. Such analysis requires a fuller trade and enterprise crosswalk than the two published headline values examined here.

Tax competition and the location of profits

Corporate income taxation influences the private value of locating an activity, holding an asset, or assigning a financial relationship to a particular jurisdiction. Changes in the expected after-tax return affect decisions alongside the cost of skilled labor, transport, credit, infrastructure, legal certainty and access to customers. An internationally mobile enterprise has more location alternatives than a business serving a small immobile local market.

The economic incidence of a concession depends on the source of mobility. If investment is highly responsive to its location-specific tax burden, an incentive may attract additional productive activity. When the principal mobility margin concerns where existing income is accounted for, a concession may stimulate less capital formation or employment per euro of fiscal cost. Real investment and the assignment of taxable profits can respond simultaneously, which creates an identification challenge.

Tørsløv, Wier, and Zucman's The Missing Profits of Nations (2023) provides peer-reviewed evidence on international profit shifting. Its relevance to the Portuguese case is methodological: profits reported in an economy and the underlying economic functions must be distinguished when considering the spatial allocation of corporate income. The results of a global study cannot establish the specific location or legality of income attributed to an individual Portuguese enterprise.

Suppose a business considers a project that would generate EUR 1 million of annual pre-tax profit under two alternative locations. The difference in statutory tax payments affects the private return, all else equal. In practice, wages, transport, customer access, risk, financing and eligibility also alter profitability. The comparison therefore requires effective tax costs and real resource costs under consistent assumptions, not a multiplication of gross revenue by a headline rate.

The effective cost also depends on the expected duration of the regime and the discounted stream of conditional benefits. If relief applies to a capped portion of income, marginal tax incentives beyond that cap differ from incentives below it. The possibility that eligibility may change following an employment or activity change makes a firm's projected benefit endogenous to its business plan.

Fiscal competition among jurisdictions can expand opportunities for firms and create pressure on governments to improve their business environments. It may also transfer revenue across borders where the same underlying economic activity remains in place. The welfare judgment depends on what actually changes: productive location, ownership attribution, public revenue, administrative costs, or the distribution of returns.

Madeira's particular case adds a regional development constraint to these general mechanisms. The purpose of an operating aid scheme concerned regional economic conditions. The effectiveness of such a measure is consequently related to local economic functions and incremental regional welfare. A higher volume of profit booked in the region can improve measured taxable income without proportionally improving employment or locally retained income. A policy appraisal must trace both effects separately.

Regional public revenue and the incidence of support

The fiscal accounting of an incentive distinguishes the nominal concession, the actual tax paid, additional revenue attributable to the induced activity, the cost of public services and administration, and the revenues affected elsewhere. The statutory benchmark offers a starting measure of foregone tax, but the business activity itself may have been absent under that benchmark. The alternative chosen for comparison changes the estimated fiscal cost.

The distinction can be expressed without assigning speculative Portuguese values. Let actual taxes from a beneficiary be T1, counterfactual taxes without the measure be T0, incremental public service and administrative costs be C, and other attributable public revenue be R. The incremental fiscal effect is T1 minus T0 plus R minus C. This is ordinary counterfactual accounting, not a proposed empirical model of estimated parameters. The quantities must refer to the same public jurisdiction and time horizon.

A regional government may receive income or consumption taxes associated with additional employment while the national government experiences a different change in corporate taxation. Foreign tax authorities may also face changes to their revenue bases. A private benefit, regional fiscal gain and national fiscal gain can have different signs. The policy assessment should specify whose welfare and fiscal accounts it measures.

The 2024 tax revenue release (DREM, 2025) identifies recovery of state aid under the IBC as one influence on regional revenue. The distinction between recurring tax collection and recovery of historical benefits is important: a large recovery may raise cash receipts in one year without improving the sustainable revenue base for future budgets. It may also affect corporate liquidity and payment timing.

An annual regional tax figure should be separated into recurring taxes, one-time recoveries, refunds, and other unusual components where the published detail permits. A comparison across years must account for differences between accrual and cash recording and for the timing of legal obligations. A budget using a volatile one-time receipt to support recurring expenditures may become more exposed to future revenue shortfalls.

The OECD's Portugal economic survey (2026) situates fiscal policy within pressures from demographic change, productivity, and public investment. Its general recommendation to evaluate tax expenditures strengthens the case for transparent measurement of geographically selective incentives. It is national evidence and supplies no estimate of the marginal fiscal effect of the Madeira regime.

Fiscal evaluation should report distribution across the public entities concerned. A benefit may be financed collectively while a large share of its private surplus accrues to nonresident investors. This does not negate benefits to resident workers or public revenue. It establishes that the incidence of the measure differs from its legal recipient and that evaluation requires explicit distributional accounting.

Banking, wealth, and external financial risk

Portugal's international financial relationships include resident banks and other financial intermediaries, household and corporate claims, portfolio and direct investment, and cross-border payments. Offshore economics asks whether the geographic structure of those relationships changes the allocation of risk and access to finance. The evidence reviewed in this dossier does not provide a Portugal-specific estimate of offshore household wealth, offshore bank deposits attributable to Portuguese beneficial owners, or the volume of legally concealed assets. Those gaps should remain visible rather than being filled with a percentage borrowed from international estimates.

Bank deposits are liabilities of the deposit-taking institution and assets of the depositor. The place of the bank, the residency of the depositor, and the identity of the party ultimately benefiting from the account may differ. Securities held in custody present a further distinction between custodian and economic owner. A financial intermediary may have a very large volume of customer assets without holding those assets as its own economic resources.

The asset/liability maturity structure also matters. A corporate group with equal asset and liability totals may face liquidity pressure if receipts arrive later than payments. Matched currency denomination reduces one category of exchange-rate exposure but leaves possible credit, settlement, legal, and operational risks. Consolidation at group level may remove internal positions from one view of the balance sheet, while national residence-based statistics retain them as cross-border claims.

The IMF's 2026 Article IV consultation reports that Portugal's current account was supported by tourism and that banking-system stability indicators had improved, while external uncertainty remained consequential. In the June 2026 vintage the reported net international investment position improved from minus 58.9 percent of GDP in 2024 to minus 50.2 percent in 2025. These national aggregates provide background for assessing international financial integration. They do not isolate the Madeira IBC, offshore deposits, or the contribution of a specific concession.

The difference of 8.7 percentage points between those annual national ratios can reflect transactions, valuation changes and growth in the denominator. Attribution to offshore activity would require a decomposition by instrument, sector and counterpart and an analysis of the change in nominal GDP. Comparing this improvement with the scale of regional enterprise statistics does not establish a causal link.

External vulnerabilities depend on exposures rather than the label attached to a financial center. Useful supervisory observations include liquidity buffers, correlated counterparties, concentration in particular jurisdictions, currency exposures and the location of effective risk-bearing institutions. A regional corporate incentive can affect some of these relationships indirectly through companies and banks serving them. The regulatory and financial data needed to quantify that link are distinct from company-license and employment counts.

National external accounts and private capital mobility

Banco de Portugal's foreign investment and external accounts analysis (2026) connects ownership to annual cross-border payments. Its note places the end-2025 inward position near 70 percent of GDP. For 2015–2025, corporations with foreign investment generated an average 44 percent of the covered exports and 55 percent of imports; income they paid to nonresidents averaged 4 percent of GDP. The analysis cannot disaggregate travel and tourism by ownership and excludes indirect spillovers through other corporations.

The result clarifies why a large stock of inward investment can coexist with significant external income outflows. A foreign-owned company may increase domestic employment and exports while also importing inputs and remunerating overseas capital. Its contribution to external financing differs from its contribution to resident welfare. An evaluation must therefore include the location of factor income, not merely foreign investment volumes. At the regional scale an analogous accounting distinction separates company output from resident wages, domestic suppliers' margins and returns accruing to nonresidents.

The international mobility of persons and private capital forms another dimension of the national context. The OECD's 2024 migration outlook records Portugal's October 2023 removal of property-purchase and qualifying capital-transfer routes under its residence-by-investment arrangement. Pereira dos Santos and Strohmaier's Golden Visas and Real Estate (2024) examines the historical property-price distortion around an eligibility threshold, using transactions from 2007–2019. The study pertains to that policy margin, not the full national housing-market effect or offshore wealth of the participants.

Corporate location incentives and residence-related incentives illustrate the same accounting distinction through different institutions. An acquisition of an existing property may transfer ownership and affect the price without creating a dwelling. A new construction project may add real capacity. Likewise, changes in corporate ownership can alter recorded investment without the creation of new productive assets. The welfare effect depends on which marginal transaction occurs. The general subject of investment migration retains its separate dossier; here the comparison explains Portuguese capital mobility and its distributional implications.

Integrity, transparency, and intermediary incentives

Cross-border finance depends on intermediaries capable of establishing ownership, authenticating records, facilitating transactions, and identifying risks. Legal, accounting, company administration and banking services reduce ordinary commercial transaction costs. They also bear responsibilities for the integrity of the financial system. The economic analysis concerns the incentives they face, the costs of verification, and the consequences of credible or deficient supervision.

The FATF's 2017 Portugal mutual evaluation describes a historically developed anti-money-laundering regime and identifies deficiencies in implementation concerning some nonfinancial professions and knowledge of legal-person risks. The evaluation is a time-specific institutional observation. It cannot serve as a 2026 compliance classification, a quantitative measure of illicit finance, or evidence against an individual enterprise.

Verification costs are integral to the price of financial intermediation. Financial institutions assess the resources required to understand complex corporate relationships and evaluate the counterparties and transactions involved. A business with predictable operations, documented ownership and an established commercial rationale may be easier to assess than an otherwise similar business whose decision-making and financial flows are difficult to reconstruct. Increasing documentation quality can reduce uncertainty without eliminating legitimate cross-border activity.

At a regional scale, ineffective controls may create reputational costs that are shared by firms unrelated to the underlying conduct. International counterparties sometimes intensify checks on an entire category of institutions when they cannot distinguish individual risks cheaply. This increases transaction costs for ordinary businesses, affects access to banking services and may reduce the attractiveness of a jurisdiction to investors who value predictable operations.

Public policy has an incentive to improve the information available for lawful transactions while avoiding indiscriminate assumptions about foreign shareholders or international capital. The enforcement of state aid conditions, anti-money-laundering obligations, and tax compliance have distinct legal objects. They can draw on complementary information without being treated as evidence of one another. Incompatible aid establishes a particular public law finding; it does not automatically establish criminal conduct. This distinction protects the integrity of the research and the interpretation of institutional records.

The economically relevant result is the quality of financial relationships, including their ability to support real investment and legitimate operations at proportionate compliance cost. Transparency has value when it enables accurate attribution of responsibility and risk, supports enforcement, and makes the conditions for participation predictable.

Labor-market evidence and the consequences of substance requirements

Madeira-specific empirical research is crucial for assessing the regional mechanism. Cabral, Peralta, Garcia, Pereira dos Santos, and Miranda's Treasure Islands, Real Jobs? (2025) examines matched employer–employee administrative data and a 2012 reform combining altered tax treatment and employment conditions. The authors compare a preannouncement worker cohort with matched workers outside the zone using an event-study difference-in-differences design. Their identification depends on comparable counterfactual trends and the absence of prior anticipatory effects; matching reduces observed differences but does not guarantee that assumption.

They report that the zone employed educated workers in specialized roles, and that the reform was followed by increased exits from covered employment records among incumbents. Remaining workers experienced wage gains; later recruits tended to have lower wages and less stable contracts relative to stayers. An exit from the dataset does not necessarily mean unemployment because the records exclude self-employment and several other employment categories. The intervention changed multiple policy margins and cannot isolate a single employment threshold. These are working-paper findings, not newly replicated results.

The evidence supports three economic interpretations. First, the presence of specialized occupational functions demonstrates why employment composition is relevant independently of the size of financial positions. A small work force can supply commercially valuable services while accounting aggregates remain substantial. Second, conditional support can affect job quality as well as employment volume. Hiring, hours, contracts and worker selection are distinct margins of response. Third, the distributional outcome depends on workers who leave or enter as well as those who remain. Average wages among stayers may change as a consequence of selection, so comparing simple pre- and post-reform averages can conceal the experience of displaced workers.

The 2024 foreign-affiliate statistics complement but do not replicate this historical study. The administrative panel analyzes individual outcomes following an earlier reform; the aggregate data describe a later cross-section of foreign-controlled companies, including the licensed subset. They inform different questions and apply to different populations. Using this distinction avoids extending the published historical treatment effects to contemporary firms without evidence.

A regional monitoring program should track employment continuity, annual working time, occupational roles, compensation and contract duration in addition to fiscal eligibility. It should assess the persistence of specialized functions after a regulatory change and estimate costs and benefits separately for residents, investors and authorities. The resulting economic appraisal can differentiate the quantity of jobs from the quality and durability of regional productive capacity.

The measurement of regional development

Regional economic development concerns the evolution of productive capacity and resident welfare over time. A program can improve measured GVA while the corresponding income accrues largely to nonresident owners; it can attract highly productive workers while increasing housing or congestion costs; it can improve access to international networks while leaving the local workforce dependent on a few mobile companies. An assessment therefore requires a set of related outcomes rather than a single headline statistic.

At the level of the worker, the relevant outcomes include resident employment, hours and compensation, access to training, mobility across employers, and the distribution of opportunities across skill categories. At the level of the business ecosystem, outcomes include entry, survival, productivity improvements, local procurement, and the formation of enduring supplier capabilities. At the public level, fiscal receipts, contingent obligations, administration and public service demands determine the net consequences for budgets.

The descriptive foreign-affiliate comparison earlier in this monograph is valuable because it separates several indicators for a defined population. It also exposes the limits of that population. Employees of locally controlled licensed enterprises are not included in the foreign-affiliate licensed subset as defined. Consequently, the reported 8.4 percent employment share cannot be treated as the proportion of total regional employment within the IBC.

Data can be organized in a consistent accounting sequence: legal entity and investor location; enterprise production and intermediate inputs; local compensation and employment; taxes and benefits; financial assets and liabilities; and ultimate income recipients where observable. The sequence connects the firm-level records used in administration to measures of regional welfare. The territorial unit and period must be preserved at each stage.

Several accounting errors are particularly consequential. Adding gross sales and GVA double counts parts of the production process. Treating nominal turnover growth as real growth ignores price changes. Combining headcount and annual work units without conversion may misstate local labor input. Treating the nominal size of financial assets as the income they produce conflates stocks and flows. Summing direct jobs and indirect jobs calculated from overlapping suppliers can double count employment.

The likely scale of each issue depends on economic function. For a manufacturing operation, physical capital and imported intermediate inputs may matter greatly. For business services, compensation and intangible assets are often central. For holding structures, financing relationships and the attribution of income deserve closer attention. The economic analyst should calculate sector-specific quantities before aggregating the regional result.

The distinction between an economically substantive activity and incremental development also deserves emphasis. A company may have genuine production and jobs in Madeira while the same company would have located there without the incentive. In that case its observed local output remains real, but the output attributable to the incentive is smaller. Public policy requires both measures for different reasons.

Evidence design and causal evaluation

The policy question is whether the incentive generates additional regional benefits relative to plausible alternatives. The descriptive statistics and institutional case study establish facts and mechanisms. A causal answer requires a comparison between the outcome for treated units and the unobserved outcome those units would have experienced without the relevant policy. The main challenge arises because companies choose whether and when to enter the regime, and the authority applies eligibility criteria that select particular kinds of business.

A research design could build a longitudinal enterprise panel combining licensing history, accounts, employment, tax data and ownership structures under appropriate confidentiality controls. The panel would identify the exact population of entities eligible under each licensing cohort and follow them before entry and after exit. Outcomes would be measured at consistent intervals with employment standardized to comparable working time where possible.

A difference-in-differences approach would require a credible control group and evidence that treated and comparison businesses had reasonably similar pre-treatment trends in relevant outcomes. A mainland comparison region may differ in accessibility, industrial mix and market size. Within Madeira, nonlicensed companies may differ systematically in orientation toward foreign markets. A comparison using both approaches could illuminate sensitivity, but neither is automatically valid.

An analysis of changes around eligibility thresholds could reveal whether firms adjust employment near a specific benefit boundary. Such a design must address manipulation of the assignment variable, anticipation, and other policy features that also change at the threshold. Bunching could reflect labor demand, reporting choices, or administrative selection. A causal design would need to evaluate those explanations and would estimate a local effect for entities near the relevant threshold rather than the total social return to the regime.

The state aid decision might provide a source of variation in expected policy treatment. However, firms subject to recovery differ in relevant characteristics from firms not subject to it. Concurrent events, including sector-specific demand changes and other public policies, can affect business outcomes. A simple before-after comparison would confound these influences. Event-study analysis would require reliable treatment timing, credible comparison units and examination of differential pre-trends.

A fiscal evaluation should distinguish mechanical effects from behavioral effects. Mechanical simulations apply alternative tax rules to a fixed observed tax base. Behavioral simulations allow the tax base, location of activity and other decisions to respond. The sensitivity of the behavioral results depends on elasticities, model assumptions, and uncertainty about outside alternatives. Observed responses in one licensing cohort may not apply to another.

The evidence obtained for this dossier is insufficient to produce a new causal estimate for the current regime. The matched-worker study reviewed above supplies estimates for a historical policy change. It supports an institutional and descriptive interpretation and motivates these feasible evaluation designs. Reporting an artificial regression result without firm-level data would be less informative than identifying precisely which data and assumptions are required. The analytical conclusions below concern the conditions under which the observed arrangements could yield regional benefits, not a fabricated point estimate of those benefits.

Comparative implications for the European offshore system

The Portuguese case contributes to the comparative economics of offshore finance by exhibiting specialization at a subnational level within a broad national economy and a supranational market. A comparison with independent financial centers must therefore account for differences in constitutional authority, statistical reporting, financial supervision, fiscal transfers, and available policy instruments.

A center that intermediates large amounts of international investment can have residents whose income depends primarily on professional and financial services. Another jurisdiction may attract productive subsidiaries or holding entities as a smaller component of a diversified national economy. A single ratio of financial assets to GDP may reveal balance-sheet intensity but cannot determine whether the economic function is predominantly destination, conduit, home economy, or a combination of these.

Madeira's regional role should be compared with other specialized regions on common measures, including employment-adjusted production, fiscal attribution, foreign-affiliate composition, and the relationship of recorded investment to economic function. A comparison limited to statutory corporate rates would omit the eligibility conditions and institutional risks that shape actual costs and benefits. A comparison of national FDI positions alone would conflate regional arrangements with much larger domestic markets.

The European dimension makes cross-border externalities an explicit part of assessment. A benefit financed through lower regional taxation can influence the location of firms, affect investment in other regions and redistribute tax bases across countries. A common institutional framework may limit distortion while still recognizing regional disadvantages. Its economic contribution is to connect public support with substantive territorial conditions and to preserve the comparability of competition.

Different policy objectives justify different measures. A program designed to compensate additional transport or operating costs calls for evidence of those costs. A program intended to generate regional employment calls for incremental resident labor outcomes. A program intended to build export capability calls for evidence on trade and value creation. The selection of a metric must follow the objective rather than the reverse.

Portugal also participates in the global system as a destination and origin of capital outside the regional program. The study of offshore-related mechanisms consequently requires national statistics and the regional case together. Neither scale alone exhausts the subject. This multiscale treatment avoids turning a single regional regime into a classification of the entire Portuguese economy.

Economic policy and research conclusions

A rigorous public evaluation could publish synchronized annual indicators for the licensed enterprise population, including cohort, activity category, standardized labor input, local wage bill, GVA, benefits received, taxes collected, and company survival. The purpose would be to distinguish the real economic effect from the financial and accounting effects of participation. Publication of aggregates can limit disclosure of confidential company-level information while preserving the possibility of independent scrutiny.

The evaluation should also define the counterfactual benchmark used for tax expenditure calculations. A comparison with the general national rate measures one mechanical difference; a comparison with what the business would actually have done captures the behavioral alternative. Both are worthwhile, and they should appear as separate quantities with sensitivity bounds.

An evidence-based approach to regional incentives should assess the marginal benefits of retaining or expanding each category of activity. Higher-value work, supplier development, capacity building and stable employment may make a program more durable. The fiscal cost of supporting a company already willing to locate in the region may be compared with the value of inducing additional functions. Such judgments require empirical estimates or explicit uncertainty rather than an assumed ranking based on legal categories.

Regulatory certainty is a complementary economic asset. Clear documentation standards and consistent verification reduce disputes concerning the geographic link between a benefit and the activity it supports. Published reporting methods help firms understand the basis on which a measure will be evaluated. Policy changes should be versioned by effective date, and administrative datasets should retain historical cohort information so that the consequences can be assessed over time.

For Portugal's external financial accounts, sectoral analysis should use standard direct investment measures together with disaggregated statistics excluding defined special-purpose entities. Further data on ultimate investor economies, pass-through activity, direct investment motives and related-party exposures would help establish the country's different roles within the international investment network. The purpose is a more faithful understanding of how savings, ownership and risk are transmitted rather than an arbitrary reduction of headline positions.

The original analytical contribution of this dossier is the joint interpretation of territorially conditioned incentives, national external balances and regional enterprise data. The calculated GVA-to-employment comparison provides a concrete illustration of why economic performance cannot be inferred from the number of licensed firms alone. The evidence points toward a research strategy that separately observes local activity, income distribution, fiscal effects and financial intermediation, then reconciles these dimensions at the level of the actual enterprise and policy cohort.

Conclusion

Portugal occupies multiple positions within the international economy. Its domestic firms and institutions invest abroad and receive investment from overseas. Its Autonomous Region of Madeira hosts a geographically targeted international business regime whose economic functions vary across industries and enterprises. The Portuguese case is most accurately examined by analyzing those functions and their institutional conditions rather than assigning an undifferentiated national label.

The documented history of Regime III establishes the economic significance of the connection between regional aid and substantive regional activity. The dispute over implementation illustrates the consequences when the geographical basis for support becomes difficult to verify. Credible eligibility can reduce public expenditure on activities unrelated to regional disadvantages, while predictable enforcement can support legitimate long-term investment.

Regional foreign-affiliate data supply a measurable example of heterogeneity: the IBC-licensed foreign-controlled subset has a much greater share of reported GVA than of employment. The derived ratio opens an economic question about capital intensity, sector mix, functions, and income attribution; it does not settle that question. Goods trade data similarly measure important commercial connections while leaving the location of the underlying value creation to further investigation.

National investment statistics require equivalent precision. Inward and outward direct investment positions establish the scale of international ownership and financing links, while special-purpose entity, ultimate-investor and transaction measures clarify their composition. The relationship between these positions and local productive capital is a matter for disaggregated evidence.

The central conclusion is that the economic value of Portugal's offshore-related arrangements depends on what the internationally distributed capital and corporate functions actually contribute, where the resulting income accrues, and how the risks and fiscal costs are allocated. Durable regional gains arise through productive capabilities, resident income, commercial networks, and sustainable public finances. These results must be distinguished from changes in legal registration and the accounting location of financial claims. The distinction enables a more rigorous assessment of Portugal's role in the global offshore system.

The findings are grounded in the specific documents and descriptive statistics identified here. A new firm-level causal estimate for the contemporary regime, full-series reconciliation, individual eligibility determinations, a complete mapping of EU authorization for every later cohort, and contemporary measurement of offshore household wealth are outside the demonstrated evidence. The November 2026 legislative proposal and April 2026 recovery action are distinguished from enacted law and adjudicated outcomes. No causal or numerical claim concerning these unmeasured quantities is made. The dossier establishes a defensible economic interpretation and identifies the empirical conditions necessary for strengthening the evidence.

References

  • Assembleia da República. (2024, November 8). Lei n.º 41/2024 [Law No. 41/2024, transposing the minimum taxation directive]. Diário da República, 1.ª série. Source.

  • Assembleia da República. (2026, November). Aprova o regime aplicável às entidades licenciadas na Zona Franca da Madeira a partir de 1 de janeiro de 2027, procedendo à alteração do Estatuto dos Benefícios Fiscais. Proposta de Lei 113/XVII/2.ª, initiative 377388. Source.

  • Autoridade Tributária e Aduaneira. (2026). Estatuto dos Benefícios Fiscais, artigo 36.º-A: Regime aplicável às entidades licenciadas na Zona Franca da Madeira a partir de 1 de janeiro de 2015 [Tax Benefits Statute, Article 36-A]. Consolidated online text, as amended by Lei n.º 73-A/2025 of December 30, 2025. Source.

  • Banco de Portugal. (2026). [Statistical analysis of the contribution of corporations with foreign direct investment to Portugal's external accounts]. BPstat, Numbers That Count, item 2945. Source.

  • Banco de Portugal. (2026). Investimento direto: nota de informação estatística de dezembro de 2025 [Direct investment: statistical information note, December 2025]. BPstat, release 2856. Source.

  • Banco de Portugal. (n.d.). Investimento direto de todos os países em Portugal, exceto SPE – transações trimestrais [Direct investment from all countries in Portugal excluding special-purpose entities – quarterly transactions]. BPstat, series 12566145. Source.

  • Cabral, S., Peralta, S., Garcia, J., Pereira dos Santos, J., & Miranda, R. (2025, March). Treasure Islands, Real Jobs? Workers and Anti-Avoidance Policies in a Tax Paradise. IZA Discussion Paper No. 17799. Source.

  • Court of Justice of the European Union. (2024, July 4). Portuguese Republic v European Commission, Case C-736/22 P, ECLI:EU:C:2024:579. Judgment of the Fifth Chamber. EUR-Lex. Source.

  • Court of Justice of the European Union. (2026, May 21). Utiledulci v Autoridade Tributária e Assuntos Fiscais da Região Autónoma da Madeira, Case C-545/24. Judgment of the Second Chamber. EUR-Lex. Source.

  • Court of Justice of the European Union. (2026). European Commission v Portuguese Republic, Case C-410/26. Notice of action brought April 22, 2026. Official Journal of the European Union, C/2026/3165. Source.

  • Damgaard, J., Elkjaer, T., & Johannesen, N. (2019). What Is Real and What Is Not in the Global FDI Network? IMF Working Paper No. 19/274. International Monetary Fund. Source.

  • Damgaard, J., Elkjaer, T., & Johannesen, N. (2024). What is real and what is not in the global FDI network? Journal of International Money and Finance, 140, 102971. doi:10.1016/j.jimonfin.2023.102971. Source.

  • Direção Regional de Estatística da Madeira (DREM). (2024, December 19). DREM releases data on foreign affiliates in the Autonomous Region of Madeira. Foreign Affiliates Statistics, 2023 reference year. Source.

  • Direção Regional de Estatística da Madeira (DREM). (2025, December 11). In 2024, the number of enterprises in the Autonomous Region of Madeira and their respective turnover and employment grew above the national average compared with 2023. Enterprise statistics, 2019–2024. Source.

  • Direção Regional de Estatística da Madeira (DREM). (2025, December 19). DREM releases data on foreign affiliates in the Autonomous Region of Madeira. Foreign Affiliates Statistics, final 2024 data. Source.

  • Direção Regional de Estatística da Madeira (DREM). (2025, June 25). DREM updates the time series of Tax Revenue Statistics with data for 2024. Regional tax revenue release. Source.

  • Direção Regional de Estatística da Madeira (DREM). (2026, September 11). DREM releases the International Trade Statistics publication for the year 2025. Final annual results, official statistical release. Source.

  • European Commission. (2020). Commission Decision (EU) 2022/1414 of 4 December 2020 on aid scheme SA.21259 (2018/C) (ex 2018/NN) implemented by Portugal for Zona Franca da Madeira (ZFM) – Regime III. Official Journal of the European Union, L 217 (August 22, 2022), 49–87. Source.

  • Financial Action Task Force (FATF). (2017, December 11). Portugal's measures to combat money laundering and the financing of terrorism and proliferation: Mutual Evaluation of Portugal, 2017. FATF. Source.

  • General Court of the European Union. (2022, September 21). Portuguese Republic v European Commission (Madeira Free Zone), Case T-95/21, ECLI:EU:T:2022:567. Judgment summary. EUR-Lex. Source.

  • International Monetary Fund. (2026, June 24). IMF Executive Board concludes 2026 Article IV consultation with Portugal. Press Release No. 26/220. Source.

  • OECD. (2024). Portugal. In International Migration Outlook 2024. OECD Publishing. doi:10.1787/50b0353e-en. Source.

  • OECD. (2025). Main concepts and definitions of foreign direct investment. In OECD Benchmark Definition of Foreign Direct Investment (Fifth Edition). OECD Publishing. doi:10.1787/7f05c0a3-en. Source.

  • OECD. (2025). OECD Benchmark Definition of Foreign Direct Investment (Fifth Edition). OECD Publishing. doi:10.1787/7f05c0a3-en. Source.

  • OECD. (2025). Special cases. In OECD Benchmark Definition of Foreign Direct Investment (Fifth Edition). OECD Publishing. doi:10.1787/7f05c0a3-en. Source.

  • OECD. (2026). OECD Economic Surveys: Portugal 2026. OECD Publishing. doi:10.1787/025b3445-en. Source.

  • Pereira dos Santos, J., & Strohmaier, K. (2024). All That Glitters? Golden Visas and Real Estate. IZA Discussion Paper No. 16857. Source.

  • Tørsløv, T., Wier, L., & Zucman, G. (2023). The Missing Profits of Nations. Review of Economic Studies, 90(3), 1499–1534. doi:10.1093/restud/rdac049. Source.